
ICMAICT 2025 Reviewers Registration Form
Terms and Conditions for Scientific Evaluation Review Process All Reviewed papers will undergo rigorous evaluation by the Scientific Committee. Reviewer comments must be relevant, constructive, and directly related to the research content. Acceptance Criteria If a paper is accepted without modifications, the reviewer must provide detailed justification for this decision. Reviews must be clear, unambiguous, and written exclusively in English to ensure compatibility with publishing standards. Rejection Criteria If a paper is rejected, the reviewer must clearly state the scientific reasons for rejection. Review Quality Standards Incomplete or overly brief reviews (e.g., lacking detailed feedback, vague statements, or insufficient justification) will not be considered valid in the evaluation process. Reviews must thoroughly assess the paper’s methodology, findings, and contribution to the field. Reviewer Recognition Upon successful completion of the evaluation, reviewers will receive a Scientific Reviewer Certificate (aligned with global standards and recognized for inclusion in Clarivate). Reviewer Comments Language : Non-English reviews will not be considered valid in the evaluation process.
Reviewers Confirmation Letter
Official Reviewer Commitment Statement:
By Complete the information of this form you declare for any assigned paper, you confirm that:
-
I will conduct a thorough, objective, and timely evaluation of the assigned manuscript according to the conference's scientific standards.
-
I will provide a complete scientific report with:
-
Constructive feedback on the paper's strengths and weaknesses
-
Clear recommendations for improvement (if applicable)
-
Proper justification for acceptance/rejection decisions
-
-
I understand that:
-
Incomplete, superficial, or delayed reviews will disqualify me from receiving:
✓ The Reviewer Certificate
✓ Any Letter of Appreciation
✓ Future review invitations -
The conference committee reserves the right to withdraw review privileges for non-compliance.
-